The Future of Learning: Adapting to the Challenges of Technology in Education
In a recent Forbes article, “How EdTech Has Fueled the Parental Rights Movement”, Apprentice Nation author Ryan Craig sheds light on the unintended consequences of technology in education, particularly focusing on the drawbacks of online gradebooks. As digital tools increasingly become integral to education and features such as grading tools are integrated into learning platforms, it’s essential to address concerns and explore solutions that strike a balance between leveraging technology for educational benefits and mitigating its negative impacts. In this response blog post, we will delve into the challenges highlighted by Craig and propose strategies for both higher education and corporate education to navigate these concerns.
Challenges and Concerns
The central issue raised by Craig is the detrimental impact of online gradebooks on the student-teacher-parent dynamic. The constant monitoring facilitated by real-time grades not only affects students’ intrinsic motivation but also leads to an influx of parent-teacher communication. The unintended consequences include heightened levels of stress for students, increased workload for teachers, and the erosion of trust between educators and parents.
Addressing Technology Concerns in Higher Education
To mitigate the negative effects of online grading in higher ed, educators are finding success in innovative approaches that can be implemented in the classroom or at an institutional level. Some examples include:
- Emphasizing Formative Assessments
- Higher education institutions should reconsider the emphasis on frequent summative assessments. Instead, there should be a shift towards more formative assessments that focus on providing feedback for improvement rather than assigning grades.
- Implementing Blackout Periods
- Institutions can consider adopting blackout periods, as recommended by Stanford’s Challenge Success. During these periods, online gradebooks could be temporarily inaccessible, allowing students to focus on learning and growth rather than fixating on constant evaluation.
- Exploring Mastery Learning
- Some institutions have successfully moved away from traditional grading systems towards mastery learning. This approach tracks students’ progress across various competencies, providing a more comprehensive understanding of their capabilities beyond a simple grade.
Addressing Concerns in Corporate Education
In the professional learning and development space, corporate e-learning educators find success in technology platforms and service providers that understand the balance of technology and soft skills. We recommend a focus on:
- Prioritizing Skill-Based Assessments
- In corporate education, a focus on skill-based assessments rather than constant grading can promote continuous learning and skill development. This approach aligns with the needs of a rapidly evolving job market.
- Integrating Learning Platforms with Workplace Tools
- Corporate education platforms can integrate seamlessly with workplace tools, fostering a more natural learning experience within the context of employees’ daily tasks. This reduces the need for constant assessment and allows for more organic skill development.
- Encouraging Lifelong Learning Mindset
- Corporate education initiatives should foster a culture of lifelong learning, emphasizing the importance of continuous improvement rather than fixed grades. This mindset shift can reduce the pressure associated with constant evaluation.
The concerns highlighted by Craig underscore the importance of reevaluating our approach to assessment in both higher education and corporate learning. By prioritizing formative assessments, exploring blackout periods, and considering mastery learning, institutions can create environments that promote genuine learning rather than an obsession with grades. In the ever-evolving landscape of education and technology, it is crucial to prioritize strategies that enhance the educational experience while minimizing the unintended consequences of digital tools.
Laurie Pulido: A Catalyst for Educational Transformation
Laurie Pulido is the Founder of Ease Learning. Her insights and expertise are often cited in industry publications on topics related to DEI principles and innovative learning design. Most recently, Laurie has been a driving force in best practices for skills-aligned learning.
Explore the Solutions
Our unique combination of learning design and development services, managed help desk support and skills assessment solutions prepare your students for the jobs of tomorrow and empower your instructors to deliver an inclusive experience for their students.
Our tech-enabled solutions identify skills gaps in your workforce. Paired with our learning design and development services we help to fill those gaps with impactful, accessible and equitable program developments, assessments and improvements.
It is vital to create accountability and transparency around validation of skills in onboarding and ongoing training programs. We help you authenticate skills for various healthcare job tracks while powering your ongoing training solutions.
“I am so grateful for your patience with us throughout this process—we’ve been able to learn a lot with this pilot and have valued you all as thought partners in that work.”
Associate Vice Chancellor of Teaching and Learning at Northeastern University
“This work has illustrated mapping of existing nursing content to the draft AACN Essentials through the Skillways platform. This offers us a way to move toward competency-based education by truly modularizing our content for small-bite delivery because we can measure progress toward outcomes as students proceed along individual paths.”
Director, ReNEW & RN-BSN Completion Programs University of Wyoming
“Thank you for all of your hard work and support! We appreciate your professionalism, knowledge, and participation in this wonderful experience to create two creative and dynamic courses.”
SME at NOCE
“Ease was always quick to work with us as an institution to quickly resolve issues. The follow up of agents was amazing.”